Humor, Irony, & Catastrophe Theory: Notes

Paulos, John Allen. Mathematics and Humor. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1980.

1 Mathematics and Humor 1
2 Axioms, Levels, and Iteration 19
3 Self-Reference and Paradox 41
4 Humor, Grammar, and Philosophy 57
5 A Catastrophe Theory Model of Jokes and Humor 75
6 Odds and the End 101
References 109
Index 113


chapter 3:
48-9: meta-joke
52: donʼt eliminate paradox?
54: Gödel

chapter 4:
57: combinatorial
60: Gestalt

chapter 5:
88: catastrophe
98: Northrop Frye

chapter 6:
102: Chomsky & Piaget
104: incongruity
105: ethnic / outsiders
106: Kuhn

See also:

Frye, Northrop. 1958. The structure of comedy. In Eight great comedies, ed. S. Barnett. New York: New American Library.

(Read 25 August 2022)

See also:

Boutot, Alain. “Catastrophe Theory and Its Critics,” Synthese, vol. 96, no. 2, August 1993), pp. 167-200.

Catastrophe theory - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

John Allen Paulos (Paulos web site)

Complications: Humor viz. irony & sarcasm

Attardo, Salvatore. “Humor and Irony in Interaction: From Mode Adoption to Failure of Detection,” in Say Not to Say: New Perspectives on Miscommunication, edited by Luigi Anolli, Rita Ciceri, and Giuseppe Riva (Amsterdam: IOS Press, 2002), pp. 159-179.

See also:

Section III - Communicate to Pretend: Irony and Humor
6. ʽ“You’re a Real Genius!”: Irony as a Miscommunication Design,ʼ by L. Anolli, M.G. Infantino and R. Ciceri, pp. 135-157;
8. “The Risks and Rewards of Ironic Communication,” by R. W. Gibbs and H.L. Colston, pp. 181-194.

Salvatore Attardo - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Garmendia, Joana. Irony (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2018), Chapter 7: Sarcasm and Humour, pp. 126 - 146.

Gibbs, Raymond W., Jr.; Bryant, Gregory A.; Colston, Herbert L. “Where is the Humor in Verbal Irony?Humor, vol. 27, no. 4, 2014, pp. 575–595.

Piskorska, Agnieszka. “A Relevance-Theoretic Perspective on Humorous Irony and Its Failure,” Humor, vol. 27, no. 4, 2014, pp. 661–685.

Tkalac, Slavko. “The Types of Incongruity and Paulosʼs Model,” Zbornik radova, vol. 24, no. 1, 2000, pp. 83-91.

Query: The structure of humorous or ironic specimens can be modelled logically, but formal logic itself cannot be ironic, can it? I would think the chain of inference must be unequivocal, even for Godel's Theorem or paraconsistent logic. (Re the stronger claims of paraconsistency—Graham Priest’s dialetheism—I have my doubts). Any formalism that generates a range of truth values must still do this consistently, or am I wrong? Even considering paradoxes and self-reference, is it not impossible, from inside of logic itself, for logic to operate ironically? Would not catastrophe theory be unequivocal in its application, or to put it less ambiguously, unequivocal in any given construct even when modeling ambiguous specimens and alternative interpretations?

It seems that natural language (and also nonlinguistic semiotic gestures, media, and nonverbal communication) constitutes something richer than the formal apparatus of logical calculi, in that we can express polysemy, self-reference, irony, meta-cognitive deliberation, and outright nonsense without restraint. And even discussing the philosophy and interpretation of formal systems must be done extraformally, so it seems, or no logicians or mathematicians would ever have argued with one another (e.g. the controversy over Cantor's bombshell on transfinites) or developed alternative philosophical conceptions.

Now it seems to me thst irony is weaker and a more general category than humor, as a punchline is not required, and irony shares the characteristic of the many-layered nature of linguistic communication (symbolism, polysemy, poetry). All of this can be graphed to unpack an expression, but it need not be done using catastrophe theory.

Contractions and Expansions
by R. Dumain

Formal Logic of Pataphysics
by René Daumal

Irony, Paradox, & Reductio ad Absurdum: Selected Online Sources

Humor & Philosophy: Selected Bibliography

Irony in Philosophy, Romanticism, & Criticism: Selected Bibliography

Irony, Humor, & Cynicism Study Guide

Ars Combinatoria Study Guide

Philosophy of Paraconsistency & Associated Logics (Web Guide)

Argumentation & Controversies: Selected Bibliography

Philosophical Style: Selected Bibliography

Jorge Luis Borges: Selected Study Materials on the Web


Paraconsistency and Dialectical Consistency
by Jindřich Zelený

Home Page | Site Map | What's New | Coming Attractions | Book News
Bibliography | Mini-Bibliographies | Study Guides | Special Sections
My Writings | Other Authors' Texts | Philosophical Quotations
Blogs | Images & Sounds | External Links

CONTACT Ralph Dumain

Uploaded 30 August 2022

©2022 Ralph Dumain